2010 Ultimate Wine Challenge Results
Ultimate Wine Challenge
June 7-11, 2010
Astor Center, New York City
A note on Ultimate Wine Challenge scoring results:
All wines were evaluated by a select group of judges under the most ideal tasting conditions, at the proper service temperature, in manageable flights of no more than eight wines; and in high-quality glassware specific for wine type and varietal.
Wines were poured into numbered glasses in a separate room, served blind in small flights based upon wine type, origin, varietal and price, and evaluated and scored by panels using a unique variation of the 100-point scale. A total of 62 individual flights were evaluated over the course of the first two days. Those wines whose average scores were 90 points and above were then evaluated on the third day in an additional round of flights as finalists, with the top scorer in 23 categories awarded the coveted Chairman's Trophy.
In addition to the award designation of Chairman's Trophy and Finalist, wines are distinguished with the following Accolades based upon final results:
95-100 Extraordinary, Ultimate Recommendation
90-94 Excellent, Highly Recommended
85-89 Very Good, Strong Recommendation
80-84 Good, Recommended
Download a printable copy of the results (PDF)
Champagne/Sparkling | White Wines | Red Wines | Dessert | Fortified
Champagne/SparklingSparkling - World |
||||||||||
| Award | Score | Product | Accolade | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chairman's Trophy | 97 | Piper-Heidsieck Rare 1999 Champagne (France), $75.00, 750 ml | Extraordinary, Ultimate Recommendation |
|||||||
| Finalist | 95 | Charles Heidsieck Rose Reserve NV Champagne (France), $75.00, 750 ml | Extraordinary, Ultimate Recommendation |
|||||||
| Finalist | 93 | Charles Heidsieck Blanc des Millenaires 1995 Champagne (France), $0.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Chairman's Trophy | 92 | Domaine Carneros Cuvee la Pompadour Rose NV Carneros (United States), $36.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 92 | Champagne Henriot Blanc Souverain NV Reims (France), $55.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 91 | Scharffenberger Brut NV Mendocino (United States), $19.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 90 | Gloria Ferrer VA de VI Ultra Cuvee NV Sonoma County (United States), $22.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 90 | Piper Sonoma Blanc de Blancs NV Sonoma County (United States), $19.99, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| 88 | Barefoot Brut Moscato NV California (United States), $10.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | Martini & Rossi NV Asti (Italy), $12.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Ballatore Gran Spumante NV California (United States), $7.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Charles Heidsieck Brut Reserve NV Champagne (France), $55.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Rotari Talento Brut NV Trento (Italy), $15.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Charles Heidsieck Millesime 2000 Champagne (France), $80.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Zonin Prosecco NV Prosecco DOC (Italy), $14.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Martini & Rossi Sparkling Rose NV Italy (Italy), $12.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Piper Sonoma Brut NV Sonoma County (United States), $19.99, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Zonin Sparkling Rose NV Italy (Italy), $14.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 84 | Barefoot Sparkling Pinot Grigio NV California (United States), $10.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 84 | Kluge Estate Sparkling Blanc de Blanc 2007 Monticello (United States), $28.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 82 | Gonzalez Byass Vilarnau Brut NV Cava - Catalonia (Spain), $14.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 82 | Kluge Estate Sparkling Rose 2007 Monticello (United States), $28.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 81 | Barefoot Rose Cuvee NV California (United States), $10.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 81 | Barefoot Premium Extra Dry Chardonnay NV California (United States), $9.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 81 | Cooks Champagne NV California (United States), $7.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 81 | Martini & Rossi Prosecco NV Italy (Italy), $14.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 80 | Barefoot Brut Cuvee NV California (United States), $9.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 80 | Brotherhood Blanc de Blancs NV Finger Lakes (United States), $10.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
White WinesChardonnay - World |
||||||||||
| Award | Score | Product | Accolade | |||||||
| Chairman's Trophy | 98 | Carpe Diem Cellars Firepeak Vineyard Chardonnay 2007 Edna Valley (United States), $24.00, 750 ml | Extraordinary, Ultimate Recommendation |
|||||||
| Finalist | 95 | Bouchard Pere et Fils Chardonnay 2007 Meursault (France), $45.00, 750 ml | Extraordinary, Ultimate Recommendation |
|||||||
| Finalist | 95 | Sonoma-Cutrer Les Pierres Chardonnay 2006 Sonoma Coast (United States), $35.00, 750 ml | Extraordinary, Ultimate Recommendation |
|||||||
| Finalist | 94 | Clos du Val Chardonnay 2008 North Coast (United States), $15.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 94 | d'Arenberg Champs Royaux Chardonnay 2008 Adelaide Hills (Australia), $35.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 94 | Gallo Family Vineyards Twin Valley Chardonnay NV California (United States), $4.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 94 | Jordan Chardonnay 2008 Russian River Valley (United States), $29.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 94 | Pietra Santa Signature Collection Chardonnay 2007 Cienega Valley (United States), $35.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 94 | Rodney Strong Vineyards Chalk Hill Estate Chardonnay 2008 Chalk Hill (United States), $20.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 93 | Handley Cellars Chardonnay 2007 Anderson Valley (United States), $20.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 93 | Rock Wall Chardonnay 2008 Santa Lucia Highlands (United States), $25.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 93 | Rock Wall Chardonnay 2008 Russian River Valley (United States), $35.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 93 | Shafer Red Shoulder Ranch Chardonnay 2008 Napa Valley (United States), $48.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 93 | Simi Chardonnay 2007 Russian River Valley (United States), $26.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 93 | Toasted Head Chardonnay 2008 California (United States), $13.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 92 | Sonoma-Cutrer Chardonnay 2008 Sonoma Coast (United States), $24.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 91 | Davis Bynum Chardonnay 2007 Russian River Valley (United States), $25.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 91 | Rex Goliath Chardonnay 2009 California (United States), $7.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 91 | Trefethen Chardonnay 2007 Napa Valley (United States), $30.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 90 | Clos du Val Calcaire Chardonnay 2007 Russian River Valley (United States), $25.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| 89 | Black Box Chardonnay 2009 Monterey (United States), $24.00, 3L Box | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 89 | Wild Horse Chardonnay 2008 Central Coast (United States), $16.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | Barefoot Chardonnay NV California (United States), $6.99, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | Blackstone Reserve Chardonnay 2007 Sonoma County (United States), $17.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | Estanica Chardonnay 2008 Monterey (United States), $11.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | Hess Collection Chardonnay 2008 Napa Valley (United States), $35.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | Mercer Estates Chardonnay 2008 Columbia Valley (United States), $15.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | Saronga Chardonnay 2009 Paarl (South Africa), $9.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Jekel Vineyards Chardonnay 2009 Arroyo Seco (United States), $12.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Robert Mondavi Winery Private Selection Chardonnay 2008 California (United States), $10.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Vendange Chardonnay NV California (United States), $9.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Woodbridge Chardonnay 2009 California (United States), $8.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Arancio Stemmari Chardonnay 2009 Sicily (Italy), $9.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Mezzacorona Chardonnay 2009 IGT, Vignetti delle Dolomiti (Italy), $8.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Monogamy Chardonnay 2007 North Coast (United States), $12.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Robert Oatley Chardonnay 2007 Mudgee (Australia), $16.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Alice White Chardonnay 2009 South Eastern Australia (Australia), $8.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Black Swan Chardonnay 2008 South Australia (Australia), $8.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Bota Box Chardonnay 2008 California (United States), $18.00, 3L Box | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Clos du Val Reserve Chardonnay 2008 Carneros, Napa (United States), $45.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 84 | Charles Krug Winery Chardonnay 2008 Carneros (United States), $20.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 84 | Gnarly Head Chardonnay 2009 California (United States), $10.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 84 | Rodney Strong Vineyards Chardonnay 2008 Sonoma County (United States), $13.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 84 | Wente Vineyards Riva Ranch Chardonnay 2008 Arroyo Seco (United States), $19.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 84 | William Fevre Champs Royaux Chardonnay 2008 Chablis (France), $23.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 83 | C.K. Mondavi Family Vineyards Willow Springs Chardonnay 2009 California (United States), $6.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 83 | Hayman & Hill Chardonnay 2008 Russian River Valley (United States), $14.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 83 | Redwood Creek Chardonnay 2008 California (United States), $8.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 83 | Turning Leaf Vineyards Chardonnay 2008 California (United States), $8.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 82 | Bennett Family Vineyards Chardonnay 2007 Russian River Valley (United States), $17.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 82 | Night Harvest by R.H. Phillips Chardonnay NV California (United States), $7.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 82 | Pietra Santa Dunne Ranch Vineyard Chardonnay 2008 Pacheco Pass (United States), $15.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 80 | Gallo Family Vineyards Cafe Chardonnay NV California (United States), $5.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
White WinesSauvignon Blanc - World |
||||||||||
| Award | Score | Product | Accolade | |||||||
| Chairman's Trophy | 92 | Nobilo Regional Collection Sauvignon Blanc 2009 Marlborough (New Zealand), $14.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 91 | Handley Cellars Handley Vineyard Sauvignon Blanc 2008 Dry Creek Valley (United States), $15.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 90 | Vina Valdivieso Sauvignon Blanc 2009 Valle Central (Chile), $8.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| 88 | Neil Ellis Sauvignon Blanc 2008 Gronekloof (South Africa), $18.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | Nobilo Icon Sauvignon Blanc 2009 Marlborough (New Zealand), $22.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Casas Patronales Reserva Sauvignon Blanc 2009 Maule Valley (Chile), $9.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Mercer Estates Sauvignon Blanc 2008 Columbia Valley (United States), $18.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Mohua Sauvignon Blanc 2009 Marlborough (New Zealand), $12.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Santa Carolina Reserva Sauvignon Blanc 2009 Casablanca Valley (Chile), $10.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Vina Ventisquero Queulat Gran Reserva Sauvignon Blanc 2009 Casablanca Valley (Chile), $18.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Black Box Sauvignon Blanc 2009 New Zealand (New Zealand), $24.00, 3L Box | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Night Harvest by R.H. Phillips Sauvignon Blanc NV California (United States), $7.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Rodney Strong Vineyards Charlotte's Vineyard Sauvignon Blanc 2009 Sonoma County (United States), $13.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Roth Estate Sauvignon Blanc 2009 Alexander Valley (United States), $15.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Vina La Rosa La Palma Sauvignon Blanc 2009 Cachapoal Valley (Chile), $7.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Monkey Bay Sauvignon Blanc 2009 Marlborough (New Zealand), $11.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Robert Oatley Sauvignon Blanc 2009 Pemberton (Australia), $16.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Villa Maria Estate Cellar Selection Sauvignon Blanc 2009 Marlborough (New Zealand), $20.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 84 | Franciscan Sauvignon Blanc 2008 Napa Valley (United States), $17.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 84 | Grove Mill Sauvignon Blanc 2009 Marlborough (New Zealand), $14.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 84 | Sebeka Sauvignon Blanc 2009 Western Cape (South Africa), $10.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 84 | Vendange Sauvignon Blanc NV California (United States), $7.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 83 | Barefoot Sauvignon Blanc NV California (United States), $6.99, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 83 | Bodega Luigi Bosca Reserva Sauvignon Blanc 2009 Mendoza (Argentina), $20.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
White WinesRiesling - World |
||||||||||
| Award | Score | Product | Accolade | |||||||
| Chairman's Trophy | 93 | Hogue Cellars Genesis Riesling 2008 Columbia Valley (United States), $15.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 91 | Hogue Cellars Riesling 2008 Columbia Valley (United States), $9.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 91 | Wakefield Riesling 2009 Clare Valley (Australia), $16.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 90 | Wagner Vineyards Dry Riesling 2008 Finger Lakes (United States), $12.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| 89 | Chateau Ste. Michelle Riesling 2008 Columbia Valley (United States), $24.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 89 | Wagner Vineyards Select Riesling 2008 Finger Lakes (United States), $12.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 89 | Wagner Vineyards Semi Dry Riesling 2008 Finger Lakes (United States), $12.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 89 | Wakefield Riesling 2007 Clare Valley (Australia), $29.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | Loredona Riesling 2009 Monterey (United States), $10.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | Mayer Am PfarrPlatz Ried Alsegg Riesling 2009 Wien (Austria), $22.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Black Swan Riesling 2009 South Australia (Australia), $8.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Jekel Vineyards Riesling 2009 Monterey (United States), $11.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Brotherhood Riesling 2009 New York (United States), $9.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Barefoot Riesling NV California (United States), $6.99, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Turning Leaf Vineyards Riesling 2008 Pfalz (Germany), $8.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 84 | Mercer Estates Riesling 2008 Yakima Valley (United States), $13.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
White WinesViognier - World |
||||||||||
| Award | Score | Product | Accolade | |||||||
| Chairman's Trophy | 92 | d'Arenberg The Last Ditch Viognier 2008 Adelaide Hills (Australia), $25.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 91 | Toasted Head Viognier 2007 Dunnigan Hills (United States), $13.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 90 | d'Arenberg The Hermit Crab Viognier 2008 McLaren Vale (Australia), $16.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| 82 | Flat Creek Estate Viognier 2009 American (United States), $18.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
White WinesPinot Grigio/Pinot Gris - World |
||||||||||
| Award | Score | Product | Accolade | |||||||
| Chairman's Trophy | 91 | Mezzacorona Pinot Grigio 2010 IGT, Vignetti delle Dolomiti (Italy), $9.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 90 | Ruffino Lumina Pinot Grigio 2009 IGT, Venezia Giulia (Italy), $9.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| 88 | Barefoot Pinot Grigio NV California (United States), $6.99, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | Bella Sera Pinot Grigio 2009 IGT, Venezia Giulia (Italy), $6.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | Nobilo Regional Collection Pinot Grigio 2008 Marlborough (New Zealand), $14.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Arancio Stemmari Pinot Grigio 2008 IGT, Sicily (Italy), $9.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Loredona Pinot Grigio 2009 Monterey (United States), $10.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Handley Cellars Pinot Gris 2009 Anderson Valley (United States), $18.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Flat Creek Estate Pinot Grigio 2009 American (United States), $18.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Robert Oatley Pinot Grigio 2009 Adelaide Hills (Australia), $16.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 84 | Black Swan Pinot Grigio 2009 South Australia (Australia), $8.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 84 | Bota Box Pinot Grigio 2009 California (United States), $18.00, 3L Box | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 84 | Mercer Estates Pinot Gris 2008 Columbia Valley (United States), $13.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 83 | Middle Sister Drama Queen Pinot Grigio NV California (United States), $12.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 83 | Tenuta ca Bolani Pinot Grigio 2009 Friuli Aquileia (Italy), $16.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 83 | Turning Leaf Vineyards Pinot Grigio 2009 California (United States), $8.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 82 | Redwood Creek Pinot Grigio 2009 California (United States), $8.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 82 | Rex Goliath Pinot Grigio 2009 California (United States), $7.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 82 | Robert Mondavi Winery Pinot Grigio 2009 California (United States), $10.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 80 | Santi Sortesele Pinot Grigio 2009 IGT, Veronese (Italy), $14.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 80 | Woodbridge Pinot Grigio 2009 California (United States), $8.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
White WinesAssorted Whites - North America |
||||||||||
| Award | Score | Product | Accolade | |||||||
| 88 | Gallo Family Vineyards Twin Valley Moscato NV California (United States), $4.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | Handley Cellars Gerwurztraminer 2009 Anderson Valley (United States), $18.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | Woodbridge Moscato 2009 California (United States), $8.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Barefoot Moscato NV California (United States), $6.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 83 | Middle Sister Wicked White NV California (United States), $12.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 83 | Vendange Symphony NV California (United States), $9.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 82 | PromisQous White NV California (United States), $12.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 82 | Wente Vineyards Small Lot 2008 Arroyo Seco (United States), $24.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
White WinesAssorted Whites - Europe |
||||||||||
| Award | Score | Product | Accolade | |||||||
| Chairman's Trophy | 94 | Fontana Candida NV Frascati (Italy), $10.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 93 | Feudo Principi di Butera Insolia 2009 IGT, Sicily (Italy), $16.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 91 | Rocca di Montemassi Calasole 2009 IGT, Bianco Maremma (Italy), $14.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 91 | Rotes Haus Gruner Veltliner 2008 Wien (Austria), $28.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 91 | Teruzzi & Puthod Rondolino Vernaccia 2009 Vernaccia di San Gimignano (DOCG) (Italy), $11.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 90 | Masseria Altemura Fiano 2009 Salento, IGT (Italy), $12.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| 89 | Cantine Lunae Colli de Luni Vermentino 2009 Colli di Luni (Italy), $19.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Bodegas Val de Vid Condesa Eylo 2008 Rueda (Spain), $14.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Ognissole VIVI VIVI Falanghina 2009 IGT, Campania (Italy), $9.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 84 | Gonzalez Byass Altozano Verdejo/Sauvignon Blanc 2008 Castilla y Leon (VdlT) (Spain), $9.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 83 | Rotes Haus Wiener Gemischter Satz Classic 2009 Wien (Austria), $28.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 83 | Sartori FERDI Garganega 2008 IGT, Veronese (Italy), $16.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 82 | Quinta do Minho 2009 Vinho Verde (Portugal), $0.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
White WinesAssorted Whites - Southern Hemisphere |
||||||||||
| Award | Score | Product | Accolade | |||||||
| Chairman's Trophy | 92 | Peter Lehmann 2009 Barossa Valley (Australia), $15.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 90 | Bodega Luigi Bosca Torrontes 2009 Cafayete (Argentina), $10.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| 89 | Alice White 2009 South Eastern Australia (Australia), $8.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 89 | d'Arenberg 2008 McLaren Vale (Australia), $25.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | Sebeka Chenin Blanc 2008 Western Cape (South Africa), $10.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Trapiche Torrontes 2009 Mendoza (Argentina), $7.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Bosman Family Vineyards Appollis (White Blend) 2009 Wellington (South Africa), $9.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
Red WinesCabernet Sauvignon - World |
||||||||||
| Award | Score | Product | Accolade | |||||||
| Chairman's Trophy | 97 | Simi Cabernet Sauvignon 2006 Alexander Valley (United States), $24.00, 750 ml | Extraordinary, Ultimate Recommendation |
|||||||
| Finalist | 96 | Pietra Santa Cabernet Sauvignon 2005 Cienega Valley (United States), $50.00, 750 ml | Extraordinary, Ultimate Recommendation |
|||||||
| Finalist | 94 | Roth Estate Cabernet Sauvignon 2007 Alexander Valley (United States), $29.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 93 | Mercer Estates Cabernet Sauvignon 2007 Columbia Valley (United States), $22.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 93 | Trefethen Cabernet Sauvignon 2006 Napa Valley (United States), $100.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 92 | Charles Krug Winery Cabernet Sauvignon 2006 Napa Valley (United States), $69.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 92 | Clos du Val Cabernet Sauvignon 2005 Stags Leap District (United States), $70.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 90 | Girard Cabernet Sauvignon 2008 Napa Valley (United States), $28.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 90 | Jekel Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon 2007 Arroyo Seco (United States), $14.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 90 | Paso Creek Cabernet Sauvignon 2007 Paso Robles (United States), $16.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 90 | Rock Wall Cabernet Sauvignon 2007 Napa Valley (United States), $30.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 90 | Sanctuary Cabernet Sauvignon 2006 Rutherford (United States), $30.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 90 | Shafer Cabernet Sauvignon 2007 Stags Leap District (United States), $70.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| 89 | Monogamy Cabernet Sauvignon 2007 North Coast (United States), $12.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 89 | Wild Horse Cabernet Sauvignon 2007 Paso Robles (United States), $19.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | Rodney Strong Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon 2007 Alexander Valley (United States), $22.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Bennett Family Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon 2006 Napa Valley (United States), $26.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Franciscan Cabernet Sauvignon 2006 Napa Valley (United States), $27.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Hayman & Hill Cabernet Sauvignon 2007 Napa Valley (United States), $14.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Jordan Cabernet Sauvignon 2006 Alexander Valley (United States), $52.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | McCrorie Family Vineyard Burly Simpkins Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon 2007 Napa Valley (United States), $70.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Clos du Val Cabernet Sauvignon 2006 Napa Valley (United States), $35.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | DFV 337 Cabernet Sauvignon 2008 Lodi (United States), $14.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Grady Family Vineyards Fine Irish Cab Cabernet Sauvignon 2008 Lodi (United States), $13.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Rocca Family Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon 2006 Napa Valley (United States), $75.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Wakefield Cabernet Sauvignon 2008 (Australia), $16.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Wakefield Cabernet Sauvignon 2005 (Australia), $49.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Wente Vineyards Southern Hills Cabernet Sauvignon 2008 Livermore Valley (United States), $14.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Night Harvest by R.H. Phillips Cabernet Sauvignon NV California (United States), $7.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Rex Goliath Cabernet Sauvignon NV California (United States), $7.49, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Robert Mondavi Winery Cabernet Sauvignon 2008 California (United States), $10.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Toasted Head Cabernet Sauvignon 2007 North Coast (United States), $12.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 84 | Blackstone Cabernet Sauvignon 2007 Sonoma County (United States), $20.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 84 | Casas Patronales Cabernet Sauvignon 2009 Maule Valley (Chile), $9.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 84 | d'Arenberg The High Trellis Cabernet Sauvignon 2008 McLaren Vale (Australia), $19.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 84 | Pietra Santa Cabernet Sauvignon 2006 Cienega Valley (United States), $20.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 84 | Woodbridge Cabernet Sauvignon 2008 California (United States), $8.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 83 | Saronga Cabernet Sauvignon 2009 Paarl (South Africa), $9.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 82 | Charles Krug Winery Cabernet Sauvignon 2007 Yountville (United States), $27.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 82 | Rodney Strong Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon 2007 Sonoma County (United States), $17.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 81 | Alice White Cabernet Sauvignon 2009 (Australia), $8.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 81 | Black Box Cabernet Sauvignon 2008 California (United States), $24.00, 3L Box | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 81 | Bota Box Cabernet Sauvignon 2008 California (United States), $18.00, 3L Box | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 81 | d'Arenberg The Coppermine Road Cabernet Sauvignon 2007 McLaren Vale (Australia), $65.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 80 | Barefoot Cabernet Sauvignon NV California (United States), $6.99, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 80 | C.K. Mondavi Family Vineyards Wildcreek Canyon Cabernet Sauvignon 2008 California (United States), $6.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 80 | Clos du Val Cabernet Sauvignon 2006 Alexander Valley (United States), $17.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 80 | Middle Sister Mischief Maker Cabernet Sauvignon NV California (United States), $12.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 80 | Moletto Cabernet Sauvignon 2003 Valdobbiadene Prosecco Superiore DOCG (Italy), $59.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
Red WinesPinot Noir - World |
||||||||||
| Award | Score | Product | Accolade | |||||||
| Chairman's Trophy | 96 | Clos du Val Pinot Noir 2007 Sonoma County (United States), $24.00, 750 ml | Extraordinary, Ultimate Recommendation |
|||||||
| Finalist | 95 | Sanctuary Bien Nacido Vineyard Pinot Noir 2007 Santa Maria Valley (United States), $33.00, 750 ml | Extraordinary, Ultimate Recommendation |
|||||||
| Finalist | 94 | Carpe Diem Cellars Firepeak Vineyard Pinot Noir 2007 Edna Valley (United States), $29.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 93 | Handley Cellars Pinot Noir 2007 Anderson Valley (United States), $30.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 93 | Sonoma-Cutrer Pinot Noir 2007 Russian River Valley (United States), $40.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 92 | Clos du Val Pinot Noir 2008 Carneros (United States), $30.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 92 | Jekel Vineyards Pinot Noir 2007 Santa Barbara County (United States), $17.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 92 | Sequana Dutton Ranch Pinot Noir 2008 Russian River Valley (United States), $40.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 91 | Irony Pinot Noir 2008 Monterey (United States), $14.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 91 | Sequana Sarmento Vineyard Pinot Noir 2008 Santa Lucia Highlands (United States), $32.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 90 | Davis Bynum Pinot Noir 2007 Russian River Valley (United States), $35.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| 88 | Blackstone Reserve Pinot Noir 2007 Sonoma County (United States), $20.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | Erath Winery Prince Hill Pinot Noir 2006 Dundee Hills (United States), $40.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | Wild Horse Pinot Noir 2008 Central Coast (United States), $24.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Domaine Carneros Pinot Noir 2008 Carneros (United States), $35.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Estancia Pinot Noir 2008 Monterey (United States), $15.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Ponzi Pinot Noir 2008 Willamette Valley (United States), $35.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Wente Vineyards Reliz Creek Pinot Noir 2007 Arroyo Seco (United States), $24.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Handley Cellars Pinot Noir 2007 Mendocino (United States), $20.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Robert Mondavi Winery Private Selection Pinot Noir 2009 California (United States), $10.99, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Vina Valdivieso Pinot Noir 2008 Valle Central (Chile), $17.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Arancio Stemmari Pinot Noir 2009 (Italy), $9.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Barefoot Pinot Noir NV California (United States), $6.99, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Bella Sera Pinot Noir 2009 Oltrepo Pavese (Italy), $6.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 84 | Lucas & Lewellen Jane Seymour’s Pinot Noir 2007 Santa Barbara County (United States), $30.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 84 | Redwood Creek Pinot Noir 2009 California (United States), $8.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 83 | Turning Leaf Vineyards Pinot Noir 2007 Oltrepo Pavese (Italy), $8.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 81 | Oak Knoll Winery Pinot Noir 2006 Willamette Valley (United States), $15.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
Red WinesMerlot - World |
||||||||||
| Award | Score | Product | Accolade | |||||||
| Chairman's Trophy | 92 | Shafer Merlot 2007 Napa Valley (United States), $48.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 91 | Clos du Val Merlot 2006 Alexander Valley (United States), $22.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 90 | Blackstone Reserve Merlot 2007 Sonoma County (United States), $20.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| 88 | Bella Sera Merlot 2008 IGT, Venezia Giulia (Italy), $6.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | Black Swan Merlot 2009 South Australia (Australia), $8.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | Northstar Merlot 2006 Columbia Valley (United States), $41.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | Paso Creek Merlot 2007 Paso Robles (United States), $16.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | Snoqualmie Naked Merlot 2007 Columbia Valley (United States), $12.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | Turning Leaf Vineyards Merlot 2008 California (United States), $8.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Bota Box Merlot 2009 California (United States), $18.00, 3L Box | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Mercer Estates Merlot 2007 Columbia Valley (United States), $22.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Mezzacorona Merlot 2007 IGT, Vignetti delle Dolomiti (Italy), $8.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Purple Cowboy Night Rider Merlot 2007 Paso Robles (United States), $12.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Wente Vineyards Nth Degree Merlot 2007 Livermore Valley (United States), $54.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Barefoot Merlot NV California (United States), $6.99, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Charles Krug Winery Merlot 2006 Napa Valley (United States), $24.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Columbia Crest Grand Estates Merlot 2007 Columbia Valley (United States), $11.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | 181 Merlot 2008 Lodi (United States), $14.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Gallo Family Vineyards Twin Valley Merlot NV California (United States), $4.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Middle Sister Forever Cool Merlot NV California (United States), $12.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 84 | Blackstone Merlot 2008 California (United States), $11.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 84 | Night Harvest by R.H. Phillips Merlot NV California (United States), $7.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 84 | Rodney Strong Vineyards Merlot 2006 Sonoma County (United States), $17.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 84 | Vendange Merlot NV California (United States), $9.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 81 | Black Box Merlot 2008 California (United States), $24.00, 3L Box | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 81 | Wild Horse Merlot 2007 Paso Robles (United States), $18.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
Red WinesShiraz/Syrah - World |
||||||||||
| Award | Score | Product | Accolade | |||||||
| Chairman's Trophy | 95 | Peter Lehmann Eight Songs Shiraz 2004 Barossa Valley (Australia), $38.00, 750 ml | Extraordinary, Ultimate Recommendation |
|||||||
| Finalist | 94 | d'Arenberg The Wild Pixie Shiraz 2008 McLaren Vale (Australia), $29.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| 88 | d'Arenberg The Love Grass Shiraz 2008 McLaren Vale (Australia), $19.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | Wakefield Shiraz 2008 Clare Valley (Australia), $16.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | d'Arenberg The Laughing Magpie Shiraz 2008 McLaren Vale (Australia), $29.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | d'Arenberg The Dead Arm Shiraz 2007 McLaren Vale (Australia), $65.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Wallaby Creek Shiraz 2008 McLaren Vale (Australia), $7.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 84 | Barefoot Shiraz NV California (United States), $6.99, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 84 | Black Swan Shiraz 2009 South Australia (Australia), $8.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 84 | d'Arenberg The Footbolt Shiraz 2008 McLaren Vale (Australia), $19.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 84 | Robert Oatley Shiraz 2007 Mudgee (Australia), $18.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 83 | Alice White Shiraz 2008 South Eastern Australia (Australia), $8.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 83 | Shafer Relentless 2006 Napa Valley (United States), $70.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 82 | Malibu Vineyards Syrah 2008 Western Malibu (United States), $25.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 81 | Fairview La Capra Shiraz 2008 South Africa (South Africa), $9.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 81 | Toasted Head Shiraz 2006 Dunnigan Hills (United States), $12.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 81 | Wakefield Shiraz 2004 Clare Valley (Australia), $49.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 80 | Vendange Shiraz NV California (United States), $9.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
Red WinesMalbec - World |
||||||||||
| Award | Score | Product | Accolade | |||||||
| 88 | Bodega Luigi Bosca Reserve Malbec 2007 Mendoza (Argentina), $20.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Dona Paula Estate Malbec 2008 Lujan de Cuyo (Argentina), $17.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Finca El Origen Reserva Malbec 2008 Uco Valley (Argentina), $10.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Bodega Luigi Bosca Malbec 2007 Lujan de Cuyo (Argentina), $24.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Redwood Creek Malbec 2009 Mendoza (Argentina), $8.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 83 | Bodegas Callia Alta Malbec 2009 Tulum Valley (Argentina), $8.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 83 | Bota Box Malbec 2009 California (United States), $18.00, 3L Box | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 82 | Bodega Luigi Bosca Gala 1 Malbec 2007 Mendoza (Argentina), $39.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 81 | Trapiche Malbec 2008 Mendoza (Argentina), $17.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
Red WinesZinfandel - USA |
||||||||||
| Award | Score | Product | Accolade | |||||||
| Chairman's Trophy | 96 | Ravenswood Zinfandel 2007 Napa Valley (United States), $18.00, 750 ml | Extraordinary, Ultimate Recommendation |
|||||||
| Finalist | 94 | Ravenswood Old Vine Zinfandel 2007 Lodi (United States), $12.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 92 | Ravenswood Telaleschi Zinfandel 2007 Dry Creek Valley (United States), $35.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| 88 | Paso Creek Zinfandel 2007 Paso Robles (United States), $16.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | Pietra Santa Zinfandel 2007 Central Coast (United States), $18.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | Ravenswood Old Vine Zinfandel 2007 Sonoma County (United States), $15.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Gnarly Head Old Vine Zinfandel 2008 Lodi (United States), $10.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Rodney Strong Vineyards Knotty Vines Estate Zinfandel 2007 Sonoma County (United States), $18.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Twisted Old Vine Zinfandel 2008 California (United States), $7.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Charles Krug Winery Zinfandel 2007 Saint Helena (United States), $25.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Redwood Creek Zinfandel 2008 Lodi (United States), $8.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Sanctuary Mariah Vineyard Zinfandel 2006 Mendocino Ridge (United States), $24.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 84 | Rock Wall Zinfandel 2008 Sonoma County (United States), $25.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 83 | Rock Wall Reserve Zinfandel 2008 Sonoma County (United States), $30.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 82 | Artezin Zinfandel 2007 Dry Creek Valley (United States), $25.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 81 | Barefoot Zinfandel NV Lodi (United States), $6.99, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 81 | Bota Box Old Vine Zinfandel 2008 California (United States), $18.00, 3L Box | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 80 | Deep Purple Zinfandel 2008 Lodi (United States), $12.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
Red WinesCabernet Franc - World |
||||||||||
| Award | Score | Product | Accolade | |||||||
| 88 | Malibu Vineyards Cabernet Franc 2008 California (United States), $30.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | Rock Wall Cabernet Franc 2008 Napa Valley (United States), $25.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
Red WinesSangiovese - World |
||||||||||
| Award | Score | Product | Accolade | |||||||
| Chairman's Trophy | 93 | Pietra Santa Sangiovese 2006 Cienega Valley (United States), $18.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 92 | Cecchi 2006 Morellino di Scansano (Italy), $20.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 92 | Ruffino 2008 Chianti Superiore (Italy), $12.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 91 | Il Ghizzano 2008 IGT, Toscana (Italy), $15.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 90 | Castello d'Albola 2007 Chianti Classico (Italy), $17.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 90 | Malibu Vineyards Vortex Sangiovese 2008 California (United States), $30.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| 88 | Bella Sera 2008 Chianti (Italy), $6.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Rocca delle Macie 2007 Chianti Classico (Italy), $15.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Ruffino 2008 Chianti (Italy), $10.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
Red WinesPetite Sirah - World |
||||||||||
| Award | Score | Product | Accolade | |||||||
| 88 | Ravenswood Vintner's Blend Petite Sirah 2007 California (United States), $10.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
Red WinesAssorted Reds - North America |
||||||||||
| Award | Score | Product | Accolade | |||||||
| Chairman's Trophy | 95 | Chateau Julien La Conviviance 2006 Monterey (United States), $90.00, 750 ml | Extraordinary, Ultimate Recommendation |
|||||||
| Finalist | 94 | J. Lohr Pau 2006 Paso Robles (United States), $50.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 90 | Franciscan Magnificat 2006 Napa Valley (United States), $50.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| 89 | Estancia Reserve Meritage 2007 Paso Robles (United States), $30.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 89 | Malibu Vineyards Meritage 2008 California (United States), $30.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | J. Lohr Hilltop 2007 Paso Robles (United States), $35.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Chateau Julien Black Nova II 2006 San Antonio Valley (United States), $78.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Hogue Cellars Genesis Meritage 2007 Columbia Valley (United States), $15.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | J. Lohr Cuvee St. E 2006 Paso Robles (United States), $50.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Blackstone Rubric 2006 Sonoma County (United States), $23.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Hess Collection 19 Block Cuvee 2007 Mount Veeder (United States), $36.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Kluge Estate New World Red 2006 Monticello (United States), $21.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Middle Sister Rebel Red NV California (United States), $12.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | PromisQous Red NV California (United States), $12.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Robert Mondavi Winery Private Selection Meritage 2008 California (United States), $10.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 84 | Clos du Val Marlstone 2005 Alexander Valley (United States), $50.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 82 | Kate & Cassie Red NV California (United States), $12.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
Red WinesAssorted Reds - Europe |
||||||||||
| Award | Score | Product | Accolade | |||||||
| Chairman's Trophy | 95 | Sartori 2005 Valpolicella (Italy), $21.00, 750 ml | Extraordinary, Ultimate Recommendation |
|||||||
| Finalist | 94 | Principe Corsini Tenuta Marsiliana Birillo 2007 IGT, Rosso Maremma (Italy), $19.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 92 | Santi Solane 2007 Valpolicella (Italy), $14.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 92 | Tenuta Rocca di Montemassi Sassabruna 2008 Monteregio di Massa Marittima (Italy), $24.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 90 | Tenuta Ca Bolani Alturio 2005 Friuli Aquileia (Italy), $24.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| 89 | Masseria Altemura Sasseo 2008 Salento, IGT (Italy), $15.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | Arancio Stemmari Nero d'Avola 2009 IGT, Sicily (Italy), $8.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | Ognissole VIVI Primitivo 2009 (Italy), $9.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Moletto Primitivo 2007 Salento, IGT (Italy), $12.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Principe Corsini Tenuta Marsiliana Marsiliana 2004 IGT, Rosso Maremma (Italy), $52.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Tenuta Rocca di Montemassi Le Focaie 2009 IGT, Rosso Maremma (Italy), $14.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Zonin 2008 Valpolicella (Italy), $18.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Feudo Principi di Butera Nero d'Avola 2008 IGT, Sicily (Italy), $16.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Perrin & Fils Vinsobres Les Cornuds 2007 (France), $22.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 80 | Mouton Cadet 2007 Bordeaux (France), $10.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
Red WinesAssorted Reds - Southern Hemisphere |
||||||||||
| Award | Score | Product | Accolade | |||||||
| Finalist | 92 | d'Arenberg The Sticks & Stones 2006 McLaren Vale (Australia), $29.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 91 | Valentin Bianchi Enzo Bianchi 2005 San Rafael (Argentina), $49.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| 88 | Bodega Luigi Bosca Finca Los Nobles Cabernet/Bouchet 2004 (Argentina), $70.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | d'Arenberg The Ironstone Pressings 2007 McLaren Vale (Australia), $65.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | d'Arenberg The Derelict Vineyard 2009 McLaren Vale (Australia), $29.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | d'Arenberg The Sticks & Stones 2005 McLaren Vale (Australia), $29.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | Sebeka Shiraz/Piontage 2008 Western Cape (South Africa), $10.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Parson's Flat Henry's Drive 2005 (Australia), $39.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Korta Carmenere 2009 Curico Valley (Chile), $8.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Cono Sur Carmenere 2007 Colchagua (Chile), $14.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | d'Arenberg The Derelict Vineyard 2007 McLaren Vale (Australia), $29.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | d'Arenberg The Galvo Garage 2007 McLaren Vale (Australia), $29.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | d'Arenberg The Custodian 2009 McLaren Vale (Australia), $19.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 84 | Casas Patronales Reserva Carmenere 2009 Maule Valley (Chile), $9.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 84 | Sebeka Cabernet/Pinotage 2009 Western Cape (South Africa), $10.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 83 | Bosman Family Vineyards Appollis (Bordeaux Blend) 2009 Wellington (South Africa), $9.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 83 | Bosman Family Vineyards Appollis (Rhone Blend) 2009 Wellington (South Africa), $9.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 83 | d'Arenberg The Custodian 2007 McLaren Vale (Australia), $19.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 83 | Korta Cabernet Franc 2009 Curico Valley (Chile), $8.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 83 | Vina Ventisquero Grey Carmenere 2008 Maipo Valley (Chile), $29.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 82 | Robert Oatley Cabernet Sauvignon/Merlot 2007 (Australia), $18.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
Red WinesRoses - North America |
||||||||||
| Award | Score | Product | Accolade | |||||||
| 83 | Barefoot White Zinfandel Zinfandel NV California (United States), $6.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 83 | Turning Leaf Vineyards White Zinfandel Zinfandel 2009 California (United States), $8.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
Red WinesSpain Reds |
||||||||||
| Award | Score | Product | Accolade | |||||||
| Chairman's Trophy | 93 | Marques de Caceres Reserva 2004 Rioja (DOC) (Spain), $25.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| 87 | Gonzalez Byass Beronia Crianza 2006 Rioja (DOC) (Spain), $13.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Familia Martinez Bujanda Casa Solar 2008 Castilla y Leon (Spain), $5.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 84 | Bodegas Luis Canas Seleccion de la Familia Reserva 2001 Rioja (DOC) (Spain), $30.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 84 | Gonzalez Byass Vinas del Vero Secastilla 2005 Somontano (Spain), $29.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 84 | Gonzalez Byass Beronia Gran Reserva 2001 Rioja (DOC) (Spain), $24.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 82 | Gonzalez Byass 2007 Spain (Spain), $19.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 82 | Red Guitar Tempranillo/Garnacha 2008 Navarra (Spain), $13.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
Red WinesPortugal Reds |
||||||||||
| Award | Score | Product | Accolade | |||||||
| 89 | Vinha de Mazouco Reserva Tinto 2007 Douro (Portugal), $0.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Planura Reserva Syrah 2007 Alentejo (Portugal), $0.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Planura Syrah 2007 Alentejo (Portugal), $0.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Vinha de Mazouco Tinto 2008 Douro (Portugal), $0.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 84 | Planura Tinto 2009 Alentejo (Portugal), $0.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
DessertLate Harvest/Botrytisized - North America |
||||||||||
| Award | Score | Product | Accolade | |||||||
| Finalist | 93 | Castello del Poggio Moscato NV Provincia di Pavia IGT (Italy), $14.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 93 | Inniskillin Icewine VQA Riesling 2007 Niagara Peninsula (Canada), $85.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 90 | Wagner Vineyards Ice Wine Vidal Blanc 2008 Finger Lakes (United States), $22.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| 89 | Inniskillin Icewine VQA Vidal Blanc 2007 Niagara Peninsula (Canada), $59.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 88 | Inniskillin Gold Icewine VQA Vidal Blanc 2006 Niagara Peninsula (Canada), $77.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 87 | Flat Creek Estate Muscato Bianco Muscat Canelli 2009 American (United States), $17.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 86 | Flat Creek Estate Muscato Da Arancia Orange Muscat 2009 American (United States), $17.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 81 | Wagner Vineyards Ice Wine Riesling 2008 Finger Lakes (United States), $24.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 80 | La Face Cache de la Pomme Neige Premiere Apple Ice Wine NV Monteregie (Canada), $30.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
DessertOther Sweet Wines |
||||||||||
| Award | Score | Product | Accolade | |||||||
| Chairman's Trophy | 94 | Etko Ltd St. Nicholas 2000 Commandaria (Cyprus), $18.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
FortifiedSherry - Spain |
||||||||||
| Award | Score | Product | Accolade | |||||||
| Chairman's Trophy | 96 | Gonzalez Byass Apostoles Very Old Rare Sherry Palo Cortado NV Jerez-Xeres-Sherry (Spain), $44.00, 750 ml | Extraordinary, Ultimate Recommendation |
|||||||
| Finalist | 95 | Gonzalez Byass Solera 1847 Superior Selection Sweet Oloroso NV Jerez-Xeres-Sherry (Spain), $17.00, 750 ml | Extraordinary, Ultimate Recommendation |
|||||||
| Finalist | 94 | Gonzalez Byass Nectar Superior Selection Sweet Pedro Ximenez Pedro Ximenez NV Jerez-Xeres-Sherry (Spain), $17.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 93 | Gonzalez Byass Tio Pepe Palomino Fino Extra Dry Palomino NV Jerez-Xeres-Sherry (Spain), $17.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
FortifiedPorto - Portugal |
||||||||||
| Award | Score | Product | Accolade | |||||||
| Chairman's Trophy | 96 | Croft NV Douro (Portugal), $32.00, 750 ml | Extraordinary, Ultimate Recommendation |
|||||||
| Finalist | 94 | Fonseca NV Douro (Portugal), $21.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 93 | Taylor Fladgate 2003 Douro (Portugal), $28.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 90 | Fonseca NV Douro (Portugal), $19.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| Finalist | 90 | Warre NV Douro (Portugal), $25.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| 85 | Croft NV Douro (Portugal), $19.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
FortifiedVermouth – World |
||||||||||
| Award | Score | Product | Accolade | |||||||
| Chairman's Trophy | 92 | Martini & Rossi Rosso NV Italy (Italy), $7.00, 750 ml | Excellent, Highly Recommended |
|||||||
| 87 | Martini & Rossi Extra Dry NV Italy (Italy), $7.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 85 | Martini & Rossi Rosato NV Italy (Italy), $9.00, 750 ml | Very Good, Strong Recommendation |
||||||||
| 83 | Noilly Prat Original French Dry NV France (France), $14.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
| 80 | Martini & Rossi Bianco NV Italy (Italy), $7.00, 750 ml | Good, Recommended |
||||||||
