Click on MORE INFO… after each individual product name below to view full results, including score, accolade, awards and downloadable icons.
Awards: CT-Chairman's Trophy; F-Finalist; GV-Great Value; T&T-Tried & True Award; T100-Top 100 Spirits. A note on the Awards & Scores.
Top 100: Spirits that are chosen as the top 100 products for this Challenge year.
Order from our affiliate ReserveBar for direct delivery.
Sort on each column by clicking column header. All products are 750ml unless otherwise noted.
| Type | Subtype | Product Name | Country | Price | Score | Awards | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Stagg, Jr., 64.2% abv MORE INFO & TASTING NOTE... | United States | $49.99 | 98 | CT | GV | T&T | T100 | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | George T. Stagg, 58.45% abv MORE INFO & TASTING NOTE... | United States | $99.99 | 97 | F | T&T | T100 | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Hillrock Exceptional Cask Solera Aged, 58.4% abv MORE INFO & TASTING NOTE... | United States | $130.00 | 97 | F | T100 | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Bib & Tucker Small Batch 6 Years Old, 46% abv MORE INFO & TASTING NOTE... | United States | $55.00 | 96 | F | T&T | T100 | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Barrell Bourbon Batch 022 5 Years Old Bourbon, 58.3% abv MORE INFO & TASTING NOTE... | United States | $89.99 | 96 | F | T100 | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Horse Soldier Reserve Barrel Strength, 58.45% abv MORE INFO & TASTING NOTE... | United States | $79.99 | 96 | F | T100 | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | William Larue Weller, 64% abv MORE INFO & TASTING NOTE... | United States | $99.99 | 96 | F | T100 | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Buffalo Trace, 45% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $24.99 | 96 | F | GV | T&T | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Four Roses Small Batch Select, 52% abv MORE INFO & TASTING NOTE... | United States | $60.00 | 96 | F | T100 | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | 1792 12 Years Old, 48.3% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $49.99 | 96 | F | GV | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Weller CYPB, 47.5% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $49.99 | 96 | F | GV | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Blanton's Gold Edition - Single Barrel, 51.5% abv MORE INFO & TASTING NOTE... | United States | $120.00 | 96 | F | T&T | T100 | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Elijah Craig Single Barrel 18 Years Old, 45% abv MORE INFO & TASTING NOTE... | United States | $119.99 | 96 | F | T100 | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Brain Brew Custom Whiskey Maple Wood, 45% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $29.95 | 95 | GV | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Blanton's Original 93 Proof, 46.5% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $70.00 | 95 | T&T | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Eagle Rare 17 Years Old, 50.5% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $99.99 | 95 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Brain Brew Custom Whiskey 36% Rye, 50.3% abv MORE INFO & TASTING NOTE... | United States | $59.95 | 95 | T100 | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Four Roses Single Barrel, 50% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $37.00 | 95 | GV | T&T | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Bowman Brothers Small Batch Virginia, 45% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $29.99 | 95 | GV | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Rock Town Four Grain Sour Mash Arkansas, 46% abv MORE INFO & TASTING NOTE... | United States | $44.99 | 95 | GV | T&T | T100 | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Weller 12 Years Old, 45% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $36.99 | 95 | GV | T&T | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Brain Brew Custom Whiskey 200 Year Oak, 45% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $34.95 | 95 | GV | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Larceny, 46% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $24.99 | 95 | GV | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Knob Creek 12 Years Old, 50% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $59.99 | 95 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Evan Williams Single Barrel 2012, 43.3% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $29.99 | 95 | GV | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Rough Rider Wilderness Hunter Single Cask, 51.35% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $40.00 | 95 | GV | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Redemption Barrel Proof 9 Years Old, 52.8% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $99.99 | 94 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Coopers' Craft Barrel Reserve, 50% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $32.99 | 94 | GV | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Doc Swinson's Finished in Madeira Casks, 46.2% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $69.00 | 94 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | TX Texas, 45% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $40.00 | 94 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Blanton's Straight From the Barrel - Single Barrel, 64.6% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $150.00 | 94 | T&T | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Chicken Cock, 45% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $59.99 | 94 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Doc Swinson's Finished in Sherry Casks, 45% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $65.00 | 94 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Fistful of Bourbon, 45% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $24.99 | 94 | GV | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Jim Beam Double Oak, 43% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $22.99 | 94 | GV | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Oak & Eden Bourbon & Spire Toasted Oak, 45% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $38.00 | 94 | GV | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Redemption Wheated, 48% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $45.99 | 93 | F | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | J Henry Limited Edition Anniversary Blend Wisconsin 2019, 63.25% abv MORE INFO & TASTING NOTE... | United States | $125.00 | 93 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Weller Antique 107, 53.5% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $49.99 | 93 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | 1792 Small Batch, 46.85% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $29.99 | 93 | GV | T&T | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Elijah Craig Small Batch, 47% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $29.99 | 93 | GV | T&T | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Elijah Craig Barrel Proof B519, 61.1% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $59.99 | 93 | T&T | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Bower Hill Special Edition #2 Sherry Cask Finished NCF, 50% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $89.99 | 93 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Larceny Barrel Proof, 61.6% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $49.99 | 93 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Old Forester 1910, 46.5% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $54.99 | 93 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Yellow Rose Outlaw, 46% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $55.99 | 93 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Eagle Rare 10 Years Old, 45% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $29.99 | 93 | GV | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Four Roses, 40% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $20.00 | 93 | GV | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Barrell Bourbon Batch 023 10 Years Old Bourbon, 53.89% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $89.99 | 93 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Horse Soldier Signature Small Batch , 47.5% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $59.99 | 93 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Rock Town Chocolate Malt Arkansas, 46% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $44.99 | 93 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Jim Beam Single Barrel, 47.5% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $39.99 | 92 | GV | T&T | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Brain Brew Custom Whiskey European Oak, 45% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $29.95 | 92 | GV | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Jim Beam Black, 43% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $22.99 | 92 | GV | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | John J. Bowman Single Barrel Virginia, 50% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $49.99 | 92 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Brain Brew Custom Whiskey Cherry Wood, 45% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $29.95 | 92 | GV | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | 1792 Full Proof, 62.5% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $44.99 | 92 | T&T | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Moylan's Cask Strength, 56.3% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $50.00 | 92 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Noble Oak Trinity Reserve, 50.3% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $59.99 | 92 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | FEW, 46.5% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $44.99 | 92 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Elmer T. Lee Single Barrel, 45% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $39.99 | 92 | GV | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Evan Williams 1783, 43% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $19.99 | 92 | GV | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Redemption High Rye, 46% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $29.99 | 92 | GV | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Abraham Bowman Twice Finished Virginia, 50% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $69.99 | 92 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | TX Texas Straight Bourbon Barrel Proof, 62.5% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $65.00 | 92 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Jim Beam White, 40% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $17.99 | 91 | GV | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Bower Hill Special Edition #1 NCF, 53% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $74.99 | 91 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Isaac Bowman Port Barrel Finished Virginia, 46% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $39.99 | 91 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | William Heavenhill 7th Edition 12 Years Old, 67.2% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $249.99 | 91 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Clyde May's, 46% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $39.99 | 91 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Weller Full Proof, 57% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $49.99 | 91 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Belfour Finished with Texas Pecan Wood, 46% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $89.00 | 91 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Hudson Whiskey Bright Lights, Big Bourbon, 46% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $39.99 | 91 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Low Gap 3 Years Old, 42.2% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $80.00 | 91 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Rough Rider Double Casked, 45% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $30.00 | 91 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Balcones Distilling Texas Pot Still , 46% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $29.99 | 90 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Elijah Craig Finished in Goose Island Bourbon County Stout Barrels, 47% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $29.99 | 90 | GV | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Bulleit Bourbon Blenders' Select, 50% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $49.99 | 90 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Weller Special Reserve, 45% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $23.99 | 89 | GV | |
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Bare Knuckle Single Barrel Cask Strength 3 Years Old, 62.4% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $55.99 | 89 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Coopers' Craft, 41.1% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $24.99 | 89 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Giant Texas 95 Proof Potstill, 47.5% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $28.99 | 89 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Maker's Mark Wood Finishing Series 2019 Limited Release Stave Profile: RC6, 54.1% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $69.99 | 89 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Old Forester 1920, 57.5% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $59.99 | 89 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Remus Repeal Reserve Series III 11 Years Old, 50% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $84.99 | 89 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Rock Town Arkansas, 46% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $39.99 | 89 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Town Branch, 45% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $35.00 | 89 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Wild Turkey Longbranch Oak & Texas Mesquite Charcoal Refined, 43% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $39.99 | 89 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Wyoming Small Batch 5 Years Old, 44% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $44.99 | 89 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Brain Brew Custom Whiskey American Oak, 45% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $29.95 | 89 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Mendocino Spirits 3 Years Old, 42.2% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $75.00 | 89 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | 1792 Single Barrel, 49.3% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $39.99 | 89 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | FEW Cold Cut, 46.5% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $44.99 | 88 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Horse Soldier Premium 2 Years Old, 43.5% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $44.99 | 88 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Jim Beam Devil's Cut, 45% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $22.99 | 88 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Old Forester Statesman, 47.5% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $54.99 | 88 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Three Chord Blended, 40.5% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $39.99 | 88 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Treaty Oak Ghost Hill Texas, 47.5% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $45.00 | 88 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Basil Hayden’s Kentucky, 40% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $39.99 | 88 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Bib & Tucker Small Batch 10 Years Old, 46% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $100.00 | 88 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Bull & Bear Kentucky, 40% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $24.99 | 88 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Redemption, 42% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $29.99 | 88 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Widow Jane 10 Years Old, 45.5% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $69.99 | 88 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Woody Creek Distillers Colorado , 45% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $44.99 | 88 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Elijah Craig Barrel Proof A120, 68.3% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $59.99 | 87 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Evan Williams Black Label, 43% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $43.00 | 87 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Stroudwater Distillery Belfry Double Barrel , 45% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $49.99 | 87 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Four Roses Small Batch, 45% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $28.00 | 86 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Smok'n Finished With Smoked Hickory Wood, 45% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $50.00 | 86 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Horse Soldier Commander's Select 12 Years Old, 48.5% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $595.00 | 86 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Brain Brew Custom Whiskey Smoked Oak, 43% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $29.95 | 85 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Old Elk 5 Years Old Wheated, 46% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $64.99 | 84 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Cleveland Underground Finished With Black Cherry Wood, 47% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $43.00 | 83 | ||
| Whisk(e)y | Bourbon | Three Chord Twelve Bar Reserve 12 Years Old, 107% abv MORE INFO... | United States | $74.99 | 82 |